3/07/2013

Inequality Of One Vote

The Tokyo High Court on Wednesday released a decision that the general election of the House of Representatives last December was against the Constitution of Japan. Although the court dismissed the demand of plaintiffs, a group of lawyers, that the election had been invalid and needed to start over, the decision cast new question on Japanese politics. Is it legitimate for Prime Minister Shinzo Abe to lead the administration?

The decision focused on whether difference of value in one vote was tolerable or not. The largest value of one vote was that in the District 3 of Kochi prefecture, which had 204,196 people who were vested voting right. But the District 4 of Chiba prefecture had 495,212. So the value of one vote in the District 3 of Kochi was regarded as 2.43 times higher than in the District 4 of Chiba. The accusers claimed that the existence of the margin was against the Constitution, which guarantees the people’s equality under the law.

The Supreme Court in March 2011, determined that when one vote had more than two times higher value than another vote, it was against the Constitution. According to the decision, the Tokyo High Court made its mind that the margin of 1:2.43 in last election was unconstitutional.

On validity of the election, however, the high court introduced “situational theory,” in which a court could dismiss the accusation, if the execution of a decision might extremely harm public benefit. Considering the trouble when the qualification of those lawmakers was denied and they lost their seats, the high court avoided ordering another election under the reasonable situation.

The Liberal Democratic Party won 294 seats out of 480. With that big gain, Abe was elected to Prime Minister. But if the general election last December was not authorized by the constitution, how the legitimacy of the administration, as well as of the representatives, is reserved? There is no provision which determines the status of Prime Minister, when the general election was invalid.

The accusers appeal that the illegitimate regime must not exercise its power. In terms of constitutionality, the policies the administration already delivered, including budget, the joint statement between the government and the Bank of Japan, or the promises in the meeting of Abe with US President Obama, might be recognized as invalid, too. Although it is unlikely for the government of Japan to deny all policies, the situation describes Japanese democracy in its half way.

3/06/2013

Double-digit Military Growth


The Government of China announced that its military budget for 2013 amounted to $118 million. It had grown by 10.7% than the result of last year. While this marked the third consecutive year of double-digit growth in comparison to the result of the year before, the double double-digit expansion is the unshaken trend of China in these twenty-five years, when it is compared to the budget at the beginning of the year before. As its result, the military budget had swollen by four times bigger than that of four years ago. So, what are they buying?

“We accelerate the modernization of national defense and military capability. Strong national defense and great military protect our nation’s sovereignty, safety and territory,” told Wen Jiabao, retiring Chinese Prime Minister, in the opening remarks of the National People’s Congress. While Chinese gross domestic product is staying at the level of 7.8%, the military budget has been growing as the nation’s central gravity.

The growth of the budget is also attributed to the increasing demand of higher salary of personnel. The pay for the troops in the Chinese Liberation Army was extremely low about ten years ago. China’s economic growth made higher payment possible. For the officials of the government and the Communist Party, it is necessary to ease the complaint of the military section for maintaining their political power basis.

One clear thing is that the Chinese military is focusing on strengthening naval power. It embarked on building its original aircraft carriers. Most suppose that it was to improve the capability of Chinese navy in East and South China Sea. The Chinese government also provided a plenty of resources with developing fighter jets with stealth capabilities. The budget for military modernizing may not be counted on the total military budget officially released. It is possible that actual amount is bigger than the announcement.

Those preparations have been recognized as attempts to enhance its power of denial. The government of Japan is raising its warning toward aggression of China, namely for the struggle over the territory around Senkaku Islands. “It is important to disclose the substance of military budget to neighbor countries and the world with transparency,” told the Minister of Defense, Itsunori Onodera.

China’s expansionism in military capability without transparency can lead to unlimited arms race in Northeast Asia. The government of Japan increased the FY 2013 budget for the Self-Defense Force for the first time in these eleven years. China seems to be ignoring this negative aspect. Looking like preparing an actual war, the leaders of China should remind of Sun-Tzu’s the Art of War, which taught that the best strategy is winning without a fight.

3/05/2013

Positive Deflation Fighter


“Japan economy was injured to heal up in three years,” told the former Prime Minister Takeo Fukuda after it get through “oil shock” in 1970s. The nominee for next governor of the Bank of Japan, Haruhiko Kuroda, on Monday declared that he intended to achieve 2% inflation target in next two years. Welcoming his announcement, Tokyo stock market marked a consecutive rally and yen declined against US dollar in the foreign exchange. With no efficient policy of raising labor wage, Japan is elevated to the higher place, where the impact of steep down will be fatal.

Kuroda has been known as a sharp critic against the policy of BoJ. In the testimony at a committee in the House of Representatives on Monday, he insisted that it had been highly unusual in the world for Japanese economy to suffer from fifteen-year long slump of deflation, and it was the central bank to be responsible for getting rid of deflation and stabilizing commodity prices. The new two-year target made clear contrast with the retiring governor, Masaaki Shirakawa, who had been reluctant to set the timeline of inflation.

It will be preferable for the government of Japan to show a cooperative situation between the executive office and the central bank in monetary policy. In that meaning, Kuroda is a better figure for the government than Shirakawa. Kuroda, as a longtime bureaucrat in the Ministry of Finance, has been better accustomed to handling politics than a lifetime BoJ banker Shirakawa is. As the most likely figure for next governor, Kuroda emphasized his closeness to Abe administration.

Another reason of positive response of market was the expectation of political stability on the nomination. The Democratic Party of Japan announced its intention not to reject Kuroda in the approval voting. With the cooperation of major opposite party, Kuroda will be approved as the governor next week. DPJ actually lost its cause to oppose Kuroda nomination in this preferable response from the market.

However, it is unclear that new BoJ policy will work. Kuroda showed positive attitude to buy more national bonds and various financial assets for increasing the money flow. But his policy embraces a risk of devaluation of assets BoJ has bought. It also is possible that commodity price will stay low level even though BoJ provide with a plenty of money.

The policy of BoJ is naturally inclined only to supply side. It is the political job to raise workers’ wage. But new tax for reconstruction from the great earthquake two years ago and raising the rate of consumption tax starting next year may weaken their purchasing power. Companies may keep their internal reserve until economical recovery would be confirmed. Complaint of consumers then may cause another political turmoil.

3/04/2013

White Devil Kills Dad


While floods and droughts are attributed to global warming, how can we find out the reason of the severe weather in this winter? A blizzard in Hokkaido, a northern island in mainland Japan, took nine lives, making them contained in a large amount of snowfalls. Having been called “white devil” in the region, that snowstorm blocked the roads on which a number of cars were passing, and left them in whiteout. Among the victims, there was a father who died in a snow, and found embracing his nine-year-old daughter. With father’s sacrifice, the daughter survived.

The father was driving his car with his daughter at the point a few miles away from his home on Saturday, when the car had to stop in the snow accumulated on the road. While he was trying to evacuate, heavy snow eventually packed up the car. He then called his friend to tell that his car could not move in the blizzard, and with his daughter embarked on walking toward his relative’s house within a mile.

They failed to reach the house and were found in front of a farmer’s garage early next morning. The father was found dead covering his daughter with his body. His body heat supposedly saved her life blocking the blizzard from her. She was weeping in extreme coldness and grievance of losing her dad, when a rescue team found her. Losing her mother two years ago, she has to live without her parents.

In another city in Hokkaido, a mother and three kids died in a car totally covered by snow. Although the official analysis of the reason is not delivered, they might have died with intoxication of carbon monoxide contained in exhaust fume that filled the car room. Other three also froze to death, while walking in the snowstorm. Experts say that it is important to stay in a car in those cases. They should have cleared the snow around exhaust pipe to let the gas escape, and call someone and wait for rescue.

This kind of tragedy anyhow happens in Hokkaido every year. To avoid fatal lost in blizzard, school would be closed when heavy weather is expected. In rural places, it is important to refrain from going out of house when a storm is coming. Every family needs to reserve foods and fuels for a few days to survive extreme weather in the winter.

Hokkaido and the coastal area of the Japan Sea is one of the places in the world with heavy snowing. Sapporo city is well known as the place for the snow festival every February. But the festival should be remembered as an attempt to overcome the white devil by enjoying snow. This is the common appeal of the Hokkaidoans, including me, to the world.

3/03/2013

Unleashing Weapons Export

The Cabinet of Shinzo Abe adopted a statement that allowed exporting parts of weapons, which had been prohibited by the policy of the government of Japan. It is a significant mitigation of rigid restriction of weapons export in a country that has been taking a distance from being involved in military conflicts. This policy change may cause increasing enemies of Japan in the world.

The impact of the statement would be defined as emasculation of the three principles on weapons export of Japan. The Cabinet of Eisaku Sato announced in 1967 unilateral ban of exporting weapons to the communist nations, to the country selected by resolution of the United Nations, and to a country in international conflict or with possibility of it. The Cabinet of Takeo Miki extended those three principles to all countries in 1976.

The former Prime Minister Yoshihiko Noda allowed exporting weapons to be beneficial for Japan’s security in a joint development or production with a country which had security cooperation with Japan. Although Noda kept basic principle of preventing promotion of international conflicts, Abe this time ignored the basic principle, leaving on the counterpart the decision of whether the weapons would be exported to the third party. It is just as saying to the importer with a wink that “ Well, we don’t care about who you are selling our weapons.”

This policy change was brought with introduction of F-35 Lightning to the Self-Defense Force of Japan. Abe administration has been looking for a chance to join the international joint production of F-35 to reduce the cost of procurement of Japanese force. But if F-35 would be sold to Israel, which is in a conflict with the Palestinian, it will go beyond the principle of “preventing promotion of international conflicts.” So, Abe set new principle that was “to be limited to users who are abiding by the purpose and principles of the Charter of the United Nations.” But it is unclear whether Japan can control the sales to the third party.

By involved in the effort to support the procurement of Israel, Japan is getting farther from the standpoint of Palestine or the Arab world. While Japan has traditionally kept its relatively neutral position in Middle East conflicts, the policy change may let Arab nations see Japan as a party of their opposite side. As we see in the assault to a natural gas plant in Algeria, Japan, regardless military or non-military, is becoming a target of terrorism. This positive attitude to developing new high-tech weapons also let neighbor countries skeptical about the intention of Japan. Persuasive reason for those who worried about Japanese militarism would be needed.

Reconstruction Gap

Kizuna, or ties, has been a common concept of reconstruction effort from the devastation of the Great Northeastern Earthquake two years ago. In the Pacific coastal area of Tohoku region, there appears the difference between the top runners and the followers. The gap is eroding the close kizuna., the Japanese once had after the disaster.

Oofunato city in Iwate prefecture is located along a bay, which cuts the land deeply. Because the city area was extended toward inland, the victims of tsunami on March 11, 2011, were relatively few. Although the stores and hotels around the Oofunato station are all broken by seawater, there recently emerged a bookstore, a drug store and a supermarket. A hotel, with a renovated building, resumed to accept travelers there. Those became possible by early start of reconstruction plan made by the city government. Fortunately enough, people in the city cooperated together for the reconstruction effort by the city.

Kesen-numa city in Miyagi prefecture, located in thirty miles south of Oofunato, sees little progress even two years later of the quake. A big ship, transported by great tsunami, stands still on the land. There are only a few new buildings around the seaport of Kesen-numa, because the city government has not get good support from people for having consensus to determine the land use. Fishery workers do not hesitate to criticize the city mayor as being “lagging behind.”

The gap between the city is mainly caused not by the lack of effort of city officials, but by rigid operation of national government. In the example of Kesen-numa city, the ministry which deals with subsidy for the reconstruction is separated depending on how to use the land. The rebuilding of berth for fishing ships is the job of the Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fishery. Reconstruction of stores and fish processing industries is dealt by the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industries. Private houses are in the category of the Ministry of Construction and Transportation. Not having enough support from all those ministries, the city government cannot have clear vision for the land use.

The responsibility should ultimately be owed by national politics. The bureaucrats in those ministries can do nothing beyond the line of existing laws. If a measure beyond the law is needed, it is lawmakers who make necessary laws to help suffering people. But most lawmakers are hesitant to make new laws against the advices of bureaucrats. It is another tragedy of Japanese nation.

3/01/2013

Be Independent


The Prime Minister Shinzo Abe required the nation to be independent in his second policy speech in current session of the Diet of Japan. Independent from what? It’s from the other people, from the government, and from the United States. Why? It’s simple. When he listed what he wanted the nation to do, he needed to ask the people to be independent from them. But if we are independent from all of them, we will be so isolated.

In the speech, he praised the independent mind of the sufferers of the Great Northeastern Earthquake in Tohoku area of Japan. “I know the people who are living in the temporary houses say ‘we encourage ourselves caring for each other,’” said Abe. He argued that it was a spirit of independence grown in the community. He did not make clear what the sufferers should do, anyway. One may recognize his message as a justification for the delay of reconstruction.

As the leader of the Liberal Democratic Party, Abe has been requiring the nation to help themselves rather than relying on public or governmental assistances. In his speech, however, he defined the spirit of social and governmental assistance to be helping each other as friends with common experiences. And in his context, sufferers of the disaster who are helping each other are described as people with independent mind. As its conceptual result, people who help themselves and who help each other are both independent.

It was not easy to understnad what he was talking about. The point he stressed was he wanted to build “strong Japan” with the power of people helping each other. But there was no reference of helping hand for people who wanted to be helped as much as he could. It would not be a prescription for growing number of suicide in Japanese society.

The Prime Minister also emphasized the need of independent diplomacy and security policy. The reason of that would easily be found. Abe met with US President Barack Obama last week. Although Obama’s staff, including the Secretary of State John Kerry, expressed US support for Japan in Senkaku issue with China, Obama himself kept his neutral standpoint between Japan and China. Obama required Japan to solve the problem in peaceful way, while he did not get involved in the sovereignty of the islands.

That was a sign that the issue needed to be solved by Japan without the nuclear umbrella of US. Abe, after the meeting, needed to encourage Japanese nations to be determined to face the problem they are facing. But Abe frequently emphasizes Chinese threat, while even former PM Jun-ichiro Koizumi, who worsened the relationship with China by going to Yasukuni Shrine, carefully referred that “ I don’t take a position of recognizing China as a threat.” It is hard for Abe administration to improve the relationship, even how we are independently determined to protect our land.