11/12/2016

Nuclear Deal Beyond Devastations

In the meeting with Indian Prime Minister, Narendra Modi, Japanese Prime Minister, Shinzo Abe, signed a deal for exporting technology on nuclear power generation on Friday. It was the second time for Japan to have nuclear agreement with a country out of the regulatory pact of Non-proliferation Treaty, following the deal with China in 1985. There was no explanation about why a country that had suffered from nuclear devastation had to proliferate nuclear technology to a country that was defying international effort to eliminate that inhumane weapon.

After severe accident in First Fukushima Nuclear Power Plant five years ago, the government of Japan laid strict regulation on developing nuclear technology, even if it would be for “peaceful” use. Meeting requirement of the business related to nuclear technology, Japan-India Nuclear agreement enables Japan exporting nuclear reactor and related devices or nuclear fuel, exchanging nuclear experts, exercising mutual development of atomic energy for peaceful purposes, and cooperating with India for studies on radiation in agriculture or medical science.

For the new deal, Japanese government insisted on setting a condition not to be used for military purposes. Japan side announced that the agreement would be suspended, if India had a nuclear experiment. “This is a legal framework to assure India taking responsible action for peaceful use of atomic energy,” said Abe in the joint press conference after the meeting with Modi.

The regulation was not written in the sentences of the deal, but in an annexed document called “Official Document on Recognition and Understanding.” The document recognizes nuclear test moratorium of India in 2008 as indispensable basis of the deal and allows Japan to end the agreement when any change in the moratorium occurs. However, India maintains its standpoint that nuclear development is its own right. Modi did not refer to the condition in the conference.

In the new diplomatic policy called Free and Open Strategy in Indian and Pacific Ocean, Abe designated Japan and India to be the leaders in making Asia-Pacific region a place for freedom, rule of law and market economy. It is inevitably a counter action against the advance of China to the region. In the situation of weaker influence of United States under the leadership of Donald Trump, Japan needs to make closer relationship with India to face China.


Sufferers from nuclear devastation were disappointed with the deal. Five organizations of nuclear sufferers in Nagasaki sent a protesting document that questioned why the only country victimized by nuclear weapons could have such a deal with India. Protestors gathered in front of Prime Minister’s official resident in Tokyo to demand not to sell nuclear power plant to foreign countries. The deal can be going beyond moral obligation of a nuclear suffered nation.

No comments:

Post a Comment