6/22/2014

Futile Questioning on History

Shinzo Abe administration submitted Budget Committee of the House of Representatives a report of investigation over Kono Statement of 1991, in which the government of Japan apologized to South Korea of involvement of Japan Imperial Army in “comfort women” scandal. The result revealed that there had been a number of consultations between the two nations over how to describe Japan’s responsibility in the statement. Although Japanese government denied reviewing the statement, the conservatives in Japan excited with those new historical facts as justification of Japan’s accusation against the Koreans.

The investigation started in February when a former Deputy Chief Cabinet Secretary indicated a possibility of consultation between Japan and South Korea right before delivering Kono Statement. The submitted report found that Japanese side consulted with South Korean government without distorting the facts. The main talking points were involvement of Japanese Army in settling brothels and in enrollment of comfort women, and coercion of enrollment.

Kono Statement admits that the brothels were build with request from Army, that enrollment was operated by private organizations with request from Army, and a lot of enrollments were overwhelmingly against the will of those women, along with temptation and coercion, and some governmental officials were involved in it. On the building brothels and enrollment, South Korea required describing it to be done by Army’s “order,” the expression which Japan rejected in the consultation. On coercion in enrollment, Korean side insisted on avoiding an image of volunteer enrollment. The expression became “overwhelmingly against the will.”

Both governments had been concealing the fact of consultation to their people. South Korean government expressed deep regret on Japan’s unilateral decision to reveal the historical fact, saying “the result of verification included substances which might erode credibility of Kono Statement.” On the other hand, it focused on the standpoint of Abe administration succeeding Kono Statement.

Conservative newspaper, Yomiuri, criticized Japanese government as ignoring facts, putting priority on South Korean opinion and inviting broad misunderstandings about direct involvement of Japanese Army.

However, even after the report revealed secret consultation between two governments, Japan is still responsible for embarrassing fact of comfort women, regardless it was operated by Japanese Army or private organization. Questioning legitimacy of Kono Statement is nothing more than complacency of the conservatives.

No comments:

Post a Comment