4/20/2017

Oyster Is OK, Mushroom Not

Discussion over creating crime of conspiracy, with which the government would punish the people before committing an actual crime, started in the Diet on Wednesday. Prime Minister Shinzo Abe stressed the necessity of the law for preemptive deterrence of terrorism. The opposite parties insisted that terrorism could be prevented without creating crime of conspiracy, which would infringe freedom of thought. However, the discussion did not work for better understandings for the people.

The bill is for revised Organized Crime Punishment Law, which is basically designed to arrest terrorist groups before committing actual terrorism. Although the government has tried to pass the bill for three times after Japan signed United Nations Convention on Transnational Organized Crime in 2000, it was dismissed with firm concern on arbitral application of the crime to the people. Japanese bureaucracy always wants to extend its arbitral power over democracy.

Abe administration keeps on attempting to persuade the public that crime of conspiracy is indispensable for Tokyo Olympic in 2020 to be successful. “Setting anti-terrorist measures is urgent issue for Japan to have Tokyo Olympic 2020. The revised law will work for preventing serious crime before it happens,” told Abe in the Committee on Judicial Affairs of House of Representatives.

To the question concerning arbitrary arresting by police or other organization for law enforcement, Abe insisted that the investigation would be appropriately exercised according to the law and no ordinary people could not be targeted. Abe’s argument made no sense, anyhow. The law can arrest innocent people, even when it is appropriately interpreted. Abe does not say that the government never arrests innocent people, but that innocent people “cannot be” arrested. While such a thing would not theoretically happen, it may happen with unexpected reason.

The law includes illegal theft in government-owned forest as crime of conspiracy. A lawmaker with Democratic Party, Shiori Yamao, asked why stealing of sea products would not be punished, if theft of mushroom in the forest would be a crime of conspiracy. The answer of an officer with Ministry of Justice was that they chose possible crimes of a criminal organization. Why would a criminal organization never commit a theft of sea products like oyster or urchin?


The opposite parties demand Abe administration abandoning the bill. If the bill passes, everyone will possibly be regarded as a terrorist, if he or she looks like committing indefinable organized crime. This anti-democratic administration encourages state power to extend its arbitrariness into private lives of the people.

No comments:

Post a Comment